ESG Report Communications: SB 253, SB 261 and CSRD
By Kyle Porter, Executive Vice President & Managing Director.
Updated November 22, 2026

What to say publicly about ESG reports in late 2026: where SB 253, SB 261 and the EU CSRD stand after the Ninth Circuit ruling, and how to word disclosures without overstating compliance.
What should a company say publicly about its ESG report in late 2026? It should state which law the report answers, which emissions scopes it covers, whether it has outside assurance, and what remains unsettled. California's SB 253 Scope 1 and Scope 2 reporting is in force, while SB 261 and SB 253 Scope 3 are preliminarily enjoined. The EU's CSRD has narrower scope after its 2026 changes.
Last updated: November 20, 2026. Legal status comes from the law-firm alerts named in the text and can change quickly, including through rehearing or Supreme Court review. This is communications guidance, not legal advice. Have counsel review every public statement.
Key takeaways
-
On November 9, 2026, the Ninth Circuit let SB 253 Scope 1 and Scope 2 reporting proceed and held that Scope 3 reporting and SB 261 likely fail strict scrutiny, according to Kirkland & Ellis.
-
The first SB 253 deadline was November 10, 2026, and it passed without court or agency action, so in-scope companies were required to report.
-
Public statements should say what a report covers and what it does not. Calling a Scope 1 and Scope 2 filing "full climate compliance" overstates it.
-
Document what you held on December 5, 2024 if you rely on California's first-year relief.
Contents
Where do SB 253, SB 261 and CSRD stand?
Three regimes matter, and each is in a different state. The table summarizes them as of November 20, 2026, using the sources named below it.
RegimeWhat it requiresStatus
California SB 253, Scope 1 and 2Annual reporting of direct and energy-related emissionsIn force. First deadline was November 10, 2026 California SB 253, Scope 3Reporting of value-chain emissionsPreliminarily enjoined by the Ninth Circuit on November 9, 2026 California SB 261Climate-related financial risk reportEnjoined since November 18, 2025. CARB will not enforce it, and submissions are voluntary EU CSRD after Omnibus 1Sustainability reporting by large companiesNarrowed in scope. Member States must transpose changes by March 19, 2027
The Ninth Circuit ruling, in Chamber of Commerce v. Sanchez, is preliminary. Kirkland & Ellis's alert of November 18, 2026 says the majority held Scope 1 and Scope 2 reporting to be commercial speech that likely survives intermediate scrutiny, with Judge Bennett dissenting. The panel unanimously held that Scope 3 and SB 261 compel noncommercial speech that likely fails strict scrutiny. The district court must decide whether Scope 3 can be severed from the rest of SB 253, and the parties have 14 days to seek rehearing.
The California regulation behind the deadline took effect on October 12, 2026, according to Arnold & Porter's October 14, 2026 analysis by Sarah Grey and Stacey Halliday. For the European Union, Freshfields reports that Omnibus 1 was published on February 26, 2026 and took effect on March 18, 2026.
Which companies do the laws cover?
California's laws cover large companies doing business in the state, and the EU rules cover large EU companies and some non-EU groups. Arnold & Porter says SB 261 applies above $500 million in revenue and SB 253 above $1 billion, with both requiring that the entity does business in California. Revenue is measured using the lesser of the last two fiscal years, and the tests apply entity by entity.
For the EU, Freshfields reports that large EU companies and groups with more than 1,000 employees and €450 million in turnover apply from financial years starting in 2027. EU subsidiaries of non-EU groups face a separate €200 million test and apply from financial years starting in 2028. Check the exact scope with counsel, because Member States are still transposing the changes.
Because applicability is decided entity by entity, a parent can file a consolidated report for qualifying subsidiaries, according to Arnold & Porter, while revenue is still assessed for each entity. A public statement should say which entities the report covers.
What should a company say publicly?
A company should say four things: which requirement the report answers, which scopes it covers, whether it has outside assurance, and what is still unsettled. That statement is short and checkable, and it avoids the claim that the report settles all climate disclosure duties.
-
Name the requirement. For example, a filing under SB 253 for the first reporting cycle.
-
State the scope. In 2026, SB 253 covers Scope 1 and Scope 2 only, according to Arnold & Porter.
-
State the assurance status. CARB will accept 2026 submissions whether or not limited assurance has been obtained, and limited assurance for Scope 1 and 2 begins in 2027, per Kirkland & Ellis.
-
Say what is unsettled. Scope 3 and SB 261 are enjoined, and the district court has yet to decide severability.
Sullivan & Cromwell's October 2026 memo on the CARB regulation notes that companies that neither collected nor planned to collect Scope 1 and Scope 2 data as of December 5, 2024 must file a statement of non-reporting to use first-year relief. If a company relies on that route, its public wording should match the filing, and it should not describe the company as fully compliant.
What does each audience need to hear?
Each audience needs the same facts at a different level of detail. The table is a drafting aid built from the sources above, and counsel should confirm each message.
AudienceWhat to tell themSource of truth
Investors and analystsFiling date, scopes covered, assurance status, what is still unsettledThe filed report and the company's own data Customers and suppliersWhether your Scope 3 requests will continue and whyCompany policy, not the court ruling alone EmployeesOne paragraph: what was filed, who owns it, where to send questionsThe same filed report ReportersA named spokesperson, the report link and a one-line status on the litigationThe filed report and counsel-approved wording RegulatorsFilings and fees as requiredCARB's instructions
CARB's fee notices are due by December 10, 2026, and payment is generally due within 60 days, according to Miller Nash. Fees may apply even to entities with reduced first-year reporting, so a finance owner should be named in the plan.
How do you avoid overstating compliance?
You avoid overstating compliance by matching each public sentence to a document. Three habits help: quote the filing, date every status, and never imply that a court ruling removed an obligation that it did not remove.
-
Do not say a law was struck down. The Ninth Circuit's ruling addresses preliminary relief only, and neither law has been struck down.
-
Do not describe SB 261 reporting as required. CARB has opened a docket for voluntary submissions, so label any climate-risk report you publish as voluntary.
-
Do not pair a sustainability claim with a figure you cannot source. The greenwashing guidance in the evolving role of PR in sustainability sets out a verification-first approach.
For examples of how companies back sustainability claims with checkable numbers, see industrial sustainability PR lessons and five sustainability PR cases and outcomes. The wider service context is in the sustainability PR hub.
What should a team do in the next 30 days?
A team should confirm its filing status, document its data, name owners and prepare statements before any new ruling arrives. Five steps cover it:
-
Confirm with counsel whether each entity met the November 10, 2026 deadline or relied on first-year relief.
-
If relying on relief, document the emissions data held or being collected on December 5, 2024, as Miller Nash advises.
-
Name one owner for CARB fees due after December 10, 2026 notices.
-
Write two holding statements, one for a rehearing or Supreme Court development and one for a CARB announcement about 2027 rules.
-
Keep building Scope 1 and Scope 2 data controls, since Kirkland & Ellis says limited assurance begins in 2027 and reasonable assurance in 2030.
Investor-facing teams can also tie this work to the company's broader disclosure calendar. The investor relations hub covers how to keep statements consistent across filings, releases and calls.
What does a holding statement look like?
A holding statement is a short, pre-cleared paragraph that a company can publish the day a ruling or a regulator's notice arrives. The template below was written for this guide as an illustration and is not taken from a real company. Counsel must adapt it to the company's actual filing.
"[Company] filed its first emissions report under California's SB 253 on [date], covering Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions for [fiscal year]. The report [has / has not] received limited assurance. A federal appeals court has paused SB 253 Scope 3 reporting and SB 261 while litigation continues, and [Company] will update this statement if the requirements change."
Each bracket is a fact the company must take from its own filing. Delete the assurance sentence if the filing does not address it, and keep the date so readers can see how current the statement is. A second version for a rehearing or Supreme Court development should be drafted now, so the team is not writing under pressure.
The sources reviewed do not prescribe who must approve such a statement, so this is a practice recommendation. Legal counsel and the executive who owns the filing should both clear the text, and the same wording should appear on the investor page, in reporter replies and in the employee note. Using one text everywhere is the simplest way to avoid two versions of the facts.
Frequently asked questions
Is SB 253 reporting still required?
Scope 1 and Scope 2 reporting is in force. The Ninth Circuit let it proceed on November 9, 2026, and the November 10, 2026 deadline passed without court or agency action, according to Kirkland & Ellis.
Is SB 261 reporting required?
No. The Ninth Circuit enjoined SB 261 on November 18, 2025, and CARB has said it will not enforce the statutory January 1, 2026 deadline, according to Arnold & Porter. Submissions are voluntary.
Does SB 253 require Scope 3 reporting?
Not now. The Ninth Circuit preliminarily enjoined Scope 3 reporting on November 9, 2026. The district court must decide whether it can be severed from the rest of SB 253.
Do companies need assurance for 2026 reports?
No. CARB will accept 2026 submissions whether or not limited assurance has been obtained. Limited assurance for Scope 1 and 2 begins in 2027, according to Kirkland & Ellis.
What changed in the EU CSRD in 2026?
Omnibus 1 narrowed the scope. Freshfields reports that it took effect on March 18, 2026, and that Member States must transpose the CSRD changes by March 19, 2027.
What should a company not say about these laws?
It should not say a law was struck down, that SB 261 is mandatory, or that a Scope 1 and 2 filing covers all climate disclosure duties. Each statement should match a filed document.
Who should approve an ESG statement?
Legal counsel and the executive who owns the filing should both approve it. The sources reviewed set no required sign-off chain, so treat this as a practice recommendation.
Where should the statement be published?
Publish the same text on the investor page, in reporter replies and in the employee note, each with the date. One wording across channels keeps the facts consistent.
Before the next ruling lands, write the four-line status statement and have counsel clear it. A company that can publish an accurate update within an hour will not have to rewrite it under pressure.
Follow us
LinkedIn





